God, Science and the Problem of Evil

Maybe...Possibly Painting by Je'Hillside, Starry Night
Painting by Je’Hillside, Starry Night

This post is in response to a twitter conversation. As you can imagine, it is difficult to discuss deep issues in 140 characters. Obviously what follows is my opinion, but then everything we think is our opinion, so here goes.

The contention was that since God cannot be proven by science, God is not real. Furthermore, if he were real, he would be a monster because terrible things happen and he is supposed to be in control of everything.

First, how do we know anything is real? If we limit what we know to what science can measure, then we are limiting ourselves too severely. Science has not only been wrong, science can be influenced by such petty things as politics and often has been. Infrared light and germs were real, but undetectable until we invented the instruments to measure them. What else is real that we don’t know about? We have NO FREAKING CLUE.

Einstein said, “Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we know or understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all that there ever was to know and understand.” In fact, Einstein came up with his theory of relativity by conducting a thought experiment. On top of all that, quantum physics claims it can prove the existence of ten dimensions mathematically.

Ten? We know three, maybe four if you want to include time. What are the other six like? We have NO FREAKING CLUE, and no way (other than imagination) to even think about them, since we are partly 3D creatures moving through a 3D world. Yet if we want to believe science, then we have to believe that there are things beyond three dimensions that are real. To exclude the possibility that one of these things is God is just a personal choice. I am in favor of personal choices, but I don’t claim that they are anything more profound than that.

My Twitter friend wanted to know how God killing people in the flood and such squares with a good God who makes everything happen. First, I don’t think God “makes everything happen.” I think humans have free will and they make a whole lot of bad things happen. Why doesn’t God stop them? Because then they don’t have free will.

Other things we think are bad like accidents and disasters are the result of our fragile bodies colliding with physical laws. Could the world go on if its physical laws were suspended? Since about 40,000 humans die daily, would God look at this the same as we do? Unlikely, but then our sadness is not ignored; the Bible says that when he saw the grief of Lazurus’ sisters, “Jesus wept.”

I have come to regard the Old Testament mostly as allegories and cautionary tales: Whatever you do, don’t do this stuff! When the writers say, “God told us,” what can that mean when they are doing things like casting lots and interpreting signs to find out what God says? People change, people progress in their insight throughout the Old Testament until you get to the prophets thundering about social justice, which sounds pretty “modern.”

Then there is a New Testament. Why was a New Testament needed? Like Jesus said, “You have heard it said in old times…but I say to you…” Genocides, racism, land-stealing, murders, revenge, none of those things are in the New Testament-quite the opposite.

But then didn’t God murder his son to satisfy his thirst for vengeance?

No! That legalistic idea is fairly recent (recent in the span of 2,000 years.) The main point, made over and over again was that Jesus was God, somehow in the form of a human being (How? I have NO FREAKING CLUE) God did not kill his son, God laid down his own human life, not to pay some vendetta but to restore us to life, to bridge the gap between humans and Life. It was an act of love, not vengeance.

I have no beef with atheists. How can I, when I was an atheist for years, then an agnostic for several more years. I was even a “religious” Hindu for awhile. I became a Christian suddenly, unexpectedly, through a personal, profound and life-changing revelation.

To get there I had to open my mind-just a crack-to the possibility that there could be a God of some sort…maybe…possibly.

That’s all the “faith” I had; not even as much as mustard seed, more like a pepper grain, really, but it was enough. 🙂






  1. Thanks for the post.
    You wrote, “First, how do we know anything is real? ”
    Science has benefited us. Yes, it has been wrong and scientific conclusions are always revisable if warranted by the evidence. Finding flaws that improve scientific knowledge is rewarded.

    You wrote: “quantum physics claims it can prove the existence of ten dimensions mathematically”. Cool, but they’ve not proven it. Still exciting to think about! Not knowing everything is a thrill, imho.

    When it comes to suggesting a deity, things get contradictory. Fast.

    Which god, yours or theirs?
    You wrote: “I don’t think God “makes everything happen”. Well, the Bible says he made the flood happen. Is this a lie? Genesis 6:13 ” And God said to Noah, “I have determined to make an end of all flesh; for the earth is filled with violence through them; behold, I will destroy them with the earth.”
    What exactly does this deity actually do? How do you know he doesn’t make everything happen? Omniscience requires he knew, prior to creating, how everything would go. Creating it anyway “makes everything happen”.

    You: ” Why doesn’t God stop them? Because then they don’t have free will.”
    Omniscience and free will are incompatible.
    Can you do something, ANYTHING, that god didn’t already know you’d do? Can you surprise him?

    You: “I have come to regard the Old Testament mostly as allegories and cautionary tales”
    So “parts” of it are true? Creation, original sin, talking serpent, the exodus, the flood? Just the Old Testament, or do you feel the same about the New Testament? An Omnipotent god “dying” (illogical), rising dead bodies galore, a place called heaven and one called hell?

    You: “God did not kill his son, God laid down his own human life”
    Allegory? “For God so loved the world that he gave his one and only Son”
    You: ” It was an act of love, not vengeance.” –
    Pretending to die…To save only “believers” from a place of eternal torment, that he created.

    You: “I had to open my mind-just a crack-to the possibility that there could be a God of some sort…maybe”
    You have a very specific god in mind. Why this one?

    1. I did not have a specific God in mind, because God by definition is beyond our feeble comprehension. I like what Einstein said, “Mine is the God of Spinoza.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s